April 21, 1999
'Tainted money?'...
'taint enough, some ministries say
___By Bruce Nolan
___Religion News Service
___NEW ORLEANS (RNS)--A former Haitian dictator reaches into his stolen wealth to help Mother Teresa's work with the homeless in Calcutta.
___Michael Milken, a Wall Street tycoon who did time for securities fraud, dispenses much of his fortune to medical research centers.
___And Percy "Master P" Miller, a businessman who built a fortune selling gangsta rap, saves a dying school for poor children.
___So, is taking charity from a dubious source agood thing or bad?
CAN TAKING DONATIONS from dubious sources taint a ministry by cooperating with evil? "That is the most interesting question in philanthropy," according to Eugene Tempel, a consultant to non-profit organizations.
___"That's the most interesting question in philanthropy," said Eugene Tempel, a consultant at Indiana University who advises non-profit organizations on, among other things, the thorny problem of "tainted money."
___There are no clear rules, of course. Or, put another way, there is only one overarching guide: "Ask what's best in the long run for all the stake-holders in the organization," Tempel said.
___But that's easy to ask, and hard to answer.
___And so it turns out that taking money from dubious sources is usually more about taking a good read on public perception than following bright ethical lines, according to conversations with several experts in the field of philanthropy.
___At one level, of course, the problem is theoretical 99 percent of the time, the kind of conflict many starving non-profit organizations only wish they could have, said Peggy Morrison Outon, who teaches the ethics of fund-raising at the University of New Orleans.
___"There's a very strong sense of poverty in non-profits," she said. "Most non-profits never have the luxury of having to engage in nice ethical discussions."
___Then, too, trolling for gifts is also the art of cultivating an institution's natural friends, said James Lee, director of development at New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary. As a practical matter, institutions don't seek gifts from potential donors with very different values.
___But what of the rare lightning bolt out of a blue sky, an unsolicited gift over the transom?
___That happened recently when Miller, responding to a private plea from a distraught grandparent, surprised church leaders with a personal check for $250,000 to his alma mater, St. Monica Elementary School, a safe harbor for poor children that had been scheduled to close in May after years of struggle.
___Miller's No Limit label is the nation's most successful marketer of gangsta rap, the widely denounced, sexually explicit music that tells the tales of mean living in tough, violent neighborhoods.
___"I have conversations with other development officers who believe that they 'clean' the money in service to humanity," Outon said.
___Mother Teresa, the Catholic nun who ministered to the abandoned dying on the streets of Calcutta, apparently took that view.
___She took money from former Haitian dictator Jean-Claude Duvalier and $1.25 million from Charles Keating before Keating's conviction for defrauding elderly clients in the collapse of his savings and loan. She even wrote Judge Lance Ito a character reference before Keating's sentencing.
___She reportedly said that, if anyone was interested in helping in the work of the Lord by helping the poor, she was happy to act as the intermediary.
___But Mother Teresa's reputation for personal poverty, along with her devotion to such a catastrophic human need, made it almost irrelevant whom she took money from, Tempel said.
___Few other institutions, however, are so armored with good will. Most are more vulnerable to public opinion, to a charge of hypocrisy that could damage their good name and their work.
___There also is a counterview to the idea that good works cleanse money, and Outon holds to the other camp.
___"When I ask for money, I'm entering an implicit contract with the donor," she said. "If I'm not proud of who that person is, of supporting them in whatever way I need to, then I don't want to be associated with them.
___"I don't think you can take a person's money and disavow him. And I don't want to partner with anyone I'm not proud to be seen with."
___In New Orleans, the Catholic church, which vigorously opposes gangsta rap, took Miller's check after examining two questions: Would taking the money amount to cooperating with evil, and would taking the money stir such a scandal the church's mission would be damaged?
___Auxiliary Bishop Gregory Aymond and Jose Lavastida, a Rome-trained moral theologian, played key roles in advising Archbishop Francis Schulte to take the money, because Miller's offer passed on both counts, they said.
___"We asked, What is the scandal--that the church has decided to accept a private donation, no strings attached, from a person who has changed?" Lavastida said.
___"Or is it that we are refusing to keep open a school that serves primarily the poor? Wouldn't that be a scandal? We'd have to wrestle with that for years."
___The key fact, in their analysis, was Miller's assurance in a conversation with Aymond that as a solo performer he was moving beyond gangsta rap, developing new lines of income in clothing and professional sports, and, in any event, his rap persona was not an accurate reflection of the man behind the lyrics.
___Even so, Miller's No Limit label still publishes records full of raw rap.
___And Aymond acknowledged this week that he came to the question equipped with only the most superficial knowledge of rappers and how they are seen by their audiences, rap culture and varying messages in rap music.
___On balance, though, Aymond and others decided early on that accepting Miller's offer, discreetly made and apparently without ulterior motive, did not amount to cooperating with evil.
___Moreover, there is no ethical obligation to determine which of Miller's dollars came from rap, and which came from other lines of income in his growing enterprise.
___That's a decision many pastors in many churches face, Lee said.
___"When a member of your church is tithing, you don't know where all that money is coming from," he said.
___That left to be addressed the notion of public scandal, requiring a real-world estimate of what would most hurt the church and ultimately the people it serves: taking the money, or walking away?
___In the end, the archdiocese's decision to take Miller's gift produced relatively little public criticism.
___It may have put church leaders in mind of a rueful observation Tempel said is common in philanthropic circles:
___"The problem with tainted money is that there 'taint enough."
___Frontpage / Contents/ Masthead / Why We're Here / Links / Archive / E-mail us/ SUBSCRIBE!