Arkansas Baptists narrowly reject opening on communion, baptism

image_pdfimage_print

Posted: 11/14/07

Arkansas Baptists narrowly reject
opening on communion, baptism

By Robert Marus

Associated Baptist Press

VAN BUREN, Ark. (ABP)—Arkansas Baptists narrowly rejected an attempt to remove a constitutional provision on communion and baptism that historians say is rooted in a 19th-century Baptist controversy.

Messengers to the Arkansas Baptist State Convention annual meeting, held Nov. 7 at First Baptist Church in Van Buren, Ark., voted 383-225 to remove the provision. However, the motion required a two-thirds majority, and it fell a few percentage points short.

The proposal would have deleted a passage that has been in the state convention’s governing documents for decades. The phrase, following a section noting that the Southern Baptist Convention’s Baptist Faith & Message also serves as the Arkansas Baptist doctrinal statement, says, “The Baptist Faith & Message shall not be interpreted as to permit open communion and/or alien immersion.”

Wes George, new Arkansas Baptist convention president

“Open communion” refers to the practice of offering the elements of the Lord’s Supper to any worshipper who is a baptized Christian, regardless of their church membership or denominational background.

“Alien immersion” refers to Southern Baptist churches accepting transfers of membership from churches of other traditions that also practice believer’s baptism by immersion.

Both terms date to the 19th century, and opposition to both practices is among the hallmarks of a Baptist movement commonly referred to as Landmarkism.

“Baptism is not a matter of heritage, history or denomination,” said Greg Addison, chairman of the state convention committee that recommended removing the provision, according to the Arkansas Baptist News. “Baptism is best and only defined by Scripture.”

Addison, pastor of the First Baptist Church of Cabot, Ark., urged reliance on the Baptist Faith & Message section and Bible passages on baptism without further interpretation. He also said the committee “affirmed that we would never step away from any process that would remove or weaken our dependence on the Baptist Faith & Message.”

Addison also argued that the passage in question conflicts with another in the Arkansas Baptist constitution that prohibits the state convention from interfering with the autonomy of local churches.

But Van Harness, pastor of Westside Baptist Church in Greers Ferry, Ark., argued against removing the phrase. He said open communion is not nearly as much a threat to the doctrinal standards of Arkansas Baptist churches as is alien immersion.

“We all agree that a valid baptism is a prerequisite for church membership,” Harness said. “When we receive someone into our church, we want to be sure they have had a valid baptism. … Only congregations that teach a correct doctrine of salvation and have a correct practice of baptism can authorize and administer a valid baptism.”

Despite the prohibitions, many Arkansas Baptist churches have long practiced open communion and accepted new members from non-Southern Baptist backgrounds without re-baptizing them.

Pastor Randy Hyde of Pulaski Heights Baptist Church in Little Rock, Ark., said his 95-year-old congregation “has never practiced closed communion, as far as I know.” He also said Pulaski Heights accepts as members those who have received believers’ baptism in other traditions.

Hyde said every time he presides at a communion service, he extends an invitation to partake for all Christians present, noting that the table of wine and bread “belongs to God” and not to the church.

“I think that’s theologically and biblically correct, and I think the Arkansas Baptist State Convention is representative of a culture that, from my perspective—at least in light of this issue—does not reflect what Scripture conveys.”

Baptist historian Bill Leonard, dean of the Wake Forest University Divinity School, said the Arkansas provision stems from the state’s history as a center of Landmarkism in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Landmarkism split many Southern Baptist congregations during that period, particularly in Tennessee, Kentucky, Arkansas, Missouri and Oklahoma. While some Landmarkists went on to form their own denominations—two are still headquartered in Arkansas—others stayed in Southern Baptist churches.

“One of the ways the state convention kept churches and pastors in the fold was to add that phrase” to its governing documents, Leonard said. “Many of those congregations look a lot more like Landmark-independent churches than they did denominationally based churches.”

The Landmarkist provisions come from an era in the South when Southern Baptists exerted much more cultural hegemony than they do today, Leonard said.

“When you had Southern Baptists as the sort of dominant, publicly privileged denomination, then many of these churches could afford to draw these lines, because people were going to join them anyway,” he said. “There were reasons enough to be Southern Baptist that churches had the luxury of drawing these distinctions.”

But today, Leonard continued, many young people and newer congregations have little or no denominational loyalty and have “no comprehension” of concepts like closed communion or alien immersion.

“There’s a kind of generic Christianity where these distinctions are difficult to make. …. But you still have a core of people for whom these are important traditions,” he said. “They are the kinds of traditions, to these people, for which changing them would be a kind of watering down.”

He added, “With Baptists, we’re all just a few steps from the 19th century at any moment.”

In other action, Arkansas Baptist messengers elected three officers who ran unopposed— Wes George, pastor of the First Baptist Church of Rogers, Ark., as president; Clay Hallmark, pastor of the First Baptist Church of Marion, Ark., as first vice president; and Robbie Jackson, pastor of East Mount Zion Baptist Church in Clarksville, Ark., as second vice president.

Messengers also adopted resolutions on encouraging church unity and opposing a state lottery. They approved a $20.5 million 2008 budget, which includes 41.97 percent for SBC causes and 58.03 percent for missions and ministries within Arkansas. The .2 percent increase for SBC causes is the first such increase in a five-year plan to increase the SBC portion by 1 percent. The 2008 budget represents a 2 percent increase over last year’s budget goal.



News of religion, faith, missions, Bible study and Christian ministry among Baptist churches, in Texas, the BGCT, the nation and around the world.


We seek to connect God’s story and God’s people around the world. To learn more about God’s story, click here.

Send comments and feedback to Eric Black, our editor. For comments to be published, please specify “letter to the editor.” Maximum length for publication is 300 words.

More from Baptist Standard