Posted: 7/06/06
Explore the Bible Series for July 16
Beware of speaking rashly for God
• Job 38:1-42:17
By James Adair
Baptist University of the Americas, San Antonio
Job has suffered incredible loss, indescribable pain and extraordinary sorrow. His three friends have added insult to injury, and the interloper Elihu has added his opinion. Job has expressed his outrage and called for justice.
At the end, the only one who has not yet been heard from is God, who now prepares to speak from the midst of a whirlwind. God’s message to Job is simple: I am sovereign, you can’t understand my ways, and you’ll just have to accept it. Is that the answer Job was looking for? Can he “just accept it”?
Job 38:1-41:34
An old preacher went to the hospital to visit a middle-aged man who had just been diagnosed with terminal cancer. He brought along a young man studying for the ministry. “How do you feel?” the old preacher asked. “I’m really mad at God!” the patient replied. “Why is he doing this to me? I don’t need a God who would do this to me, and I don’t want a God who’s too weak to stop it from happening. I hate God, I hate him!”
And he began to cry. The old preacher spoke a few words of comfort, offered a brief prayer and left the sick man to himself. After they were out in the hall, the seminary student said to the preacher with astonishment: “How could you just stand there and not say anything while that man was raving? All those things he said about God just weren’t right! Why didn’t you set him straight?”
With a look of compassion, the old preacher put his right hand on the student’s shoulder. “Son,” he said: “Don’t you worry about anything. God’s a big boy; he can take care of himself.”
Like the young man, and Job’s friends, we often feel the need to correct those who are railing against God. “No, God’s not unfair! God’s not capricious! God does care!”
Elihu is an enigmatic character who suddenly appears at the beginning of Job chapter 32 and disappears just as suddenly at the end of chapter 37. He criticizes Job’s friends for failing to answer Job’s complaints, he criticizes Job for justifying himself before God, and he claims his words are the words of God. God is not unjust, he says, for God knows everything people do, so God’s actions always are right.
Elihu’s understanding of God and the universe is comprehensive, logically consistent and wrong.
Though the opening words of God’s soliloquy in chapter 38—“Who is this that darkens counsel by words without knowledge?”— might have originally applied to Job, in the canonical structure of the book, they also apply to Elihu, perhaps primarily to Elihu.
God rebukes Job for his lack of understanding, but God’s dismissal of the words of Elihu as “words without knowledge,” without any further reference to him, suggests a greater condemnation. One thing Job had in common with his three friends and Elihu is that none of them understood as much about God as they claimed. God’s speeches illustrate his great power and wisdom, and the implication of the speeches to Job and the others is this: “If you can’t understand my works, and you can’t replicate my power, how can you debate with me about my justice?”
Job 42:1-17
When my daughter was about 3 years old, my wife was trying to get her dressed to go somewhere, and she was putting up a fight about wearing some pants. The phone rang, and my mother-in-law was on the phone, so my wife talked to her for a few minutes in Spanish.
After she got off the phone, my daughter, still adamant about not cooperating, said to her, “Ooga booga!” “What does that mean?” my wife asked. “It means I don’t want to wear pants, and I don’t have to!” my daughter replied. In her ignorance of the ways of the world, she assumed that since she couldn’t understand Spanish, it must just be a bunch of gibberish, so she figured she could make up her own language as well.
Comparing a 3-year-old child’s understanding of the world with an adult’s is analogous to comparing an adult’s understanding to God’s, as Job discovered. Job had been through a lot in recent days: The loss of his possessions, the loss of his children and the loss of his health. He thought he understood how God worked, and he was mad because God seemed to be violating God’s own code of conduct.
Why had God allowed all these terrible things to happen to him when he was God’s faithful servant? Why did God let the wicked run roughshod over the good? God had to be called to account!
In his ignorance, Job challenged God to appear before him. Much to his surprise and chagrin, God took him up on his challenge. It is interesting to note that God never answers any of Job’s questions directly. God refuses to be judged by humanity’s puny intellect.
Instead, God issues intellectual challenges to Job to ascertain whether he really is ready to sit in judgment upon God. Since Job is completely unable to answer God’s questions, it is clear the trial of God will not occur with Job as judge.
Instead, recognizing the profundity of his own ignorance, Job humbly repents, and God accepts him.
Verses 7-9 are crucial to understanding this chapter and the whole book. God is angry with Job’s friends because they have not spoken correctly concerning God, while Job has.
What? Job said God was unfair, that God allowed injustice in the world and that God had punished him for no good reason. Was he right after all?
Yes! By human standards, at least, everything Job said was true, and God praises him for his perception. Job may have spoken in ignorance, but his friends spoke in presumption. Job may not have had a very good understanding of the ways of God, but his understanding was much better than his friends.
Furthermore, while Job spoke rashly to God, he didn’t speak rashly for God, as his friends had. Job prays for his friends’ forgiveness, God accepts his prayer, and all is restored. Job’s family and friends bring him gifts, and before too long, Job has twice as much wealth and 10 new children.
Contrary to expectations, the story of Job has a happy ending. The present form of the book may mask the fact that many, perhaps most, who suffer do not end their lives in prosperity. Their personal book of Job stops at the end of chapter 41.
For them, the words of Job—which God praised as right—are their own words, which they address to those of us who are not suffering: “Have pity on me, have pity on me, O you my friends, for the hand of God has touched me!” (Job 19:21). Let us respond to our own suffering with faith and to the suffering of others with mercy.
Discussion questions
• What do you think Job’s reaction would have been had God revealed to him the wager between God and Satan? Why did God decline to mention it?
• Is it appropriate to express our true feelings about God to God or others?
• Is “praise the Lord anyway” appropriate or realistic in every situation?
• What is the difference between speaking to God, speaking about God, and speaking for God? What are the potential benefits and dangers of each?
News of religion, faith, missions, Bible study and Christian ministry among Texas Baptist churches, in the BGCT, the Southern Baptist Convention ( SBC ) and around the world.