NASHVILLE, Tenn.—Most Protestant pastors feel confident about the discipleship taking place in their churches. However, there’s still plenty of room for growth, according to a new study from Nashville-based LifeWay Research.
About two-thirds (65 percent) say they are satisfied with the state of discipleship and spiritual formation in their local church, while 78 percent indicate there’s room for improvement.
While two-thirds agree they are satisfied with discipleship, 44 percent are not regularly evaluating discipleship progress to inform that opinion. About eight out of 10 (83 percent) have an intentional plan for discipleship.
“Following Christ involves movement,” said Scott McConnell, executive director of LifeWay Research. “And that movement can either be walking with Christ or straying from that path. Churches must be vigilant and proactive in encouraging the progress of believers.”
More pastors today say they are satisfied with the state of discipleship in their church than seven years ago. In a similar survey by LifeWay Research in 2011, less than half (47 percent) were satisfied.
In the 2019 study, 55 percent of Protestant pastors say they regularly evaluate discipleship progress of their congregations. That’s up from 43 percent of pastors who answered “yes” to the same question in 2011.
“As pastors increasingly value measurement of discipleship, it is important to note that growth in Christlikeness is more than having new people to fill places of service at church,” McConnell said. “Our journey with Christ involves our beliefs, attitudes and behaviors, so we need evaluation in all of these areas.”
Churches use many approaches to disciple and encourage spiritual development in adults, the study found. On average, churches chose more than six of the nine approaches listed in the survey. Sunday School and ongoing small group Bible studies are the most common discipleship approaches followed by sermons, women’s groups and short-term Bible studies.
“In a broad sense, discipleship is really an intentional and consistent effort, driven by faith, to follow Jesus,” said Michael Kelley, director of Discipleship and Groups Ministry at LifeWay Christian Resources. “But the specific dynamics of how discipleship happens in an individual church vary based on the context of that local church.”
When it comes to the question of on-campus or off-campus small group Bible studies, almost all Protestant pastors (96 percent) say they have ongoing adult Sunday School or small group Bible studies at the church building. Slightly more than half (53 percent) say they have small group Bible studies that meet in homes or outside the church building.
Pastors of small to mid-size churches tend to choose on-campus Bible studies exclusively. Most pastors of churches with an attendance of 49 or fewer (89 percent), 50-99 (97 percent), 100-249 (97 percent), and 250-plus (96 percent) say they have on-campus Sunday School or small group studies for adults.
At the same time, pastors of churches with attendance of 250-plus are most likely to use off-campus small groups (77 percent).
Differences by age, region and ethnicity
The pastor survey also reveals demographic differences by age, region and ethnicity, as well as church size and denomination:
- Pastors of churches with attendance of 100-249 (70 percent) are more likely to say they are satisfied with the state of discipleship in their church than those with attendance of 50-99 (61 percent). Pentecostals (75 percent) are more likely to agree than Baptists (63 percent) and Methodists (54 percent)
- Pastors age 45-54 (88 percent) are more likely to say their church has an intentional plan for discipleship of individuals and encouraging their spiritual growth when compared to those 55-64 (80 percent). Non-white pastors (91 percent) are more likely to say they have an intentional plan than white pastors (82 percent).
- Pastors in the South (59 percent) are more likely to say they evaluate discipleship progress in their church than those in the Midwest (51 percent). Pastors age 18-44 (60 percent) are more likely to evaluate their church’s progress than those 65 and older (49 percent).
Signposts of spiritual health
“The majority of older pastors grew up in churches where discipleship was assumed to be taking place,” McConnell said. “More younger pastors realize it’s something that must be tracked.”
LifeWay Research has been studying discipleship and spiritual growth for 30 years, McConnell noted.
Since 2007, LifeWay Research has surveyed more than 7,000 churchgoers as part of national samples of Protestants in the U.S. to discover and improve measures of spiritual formation.
Eight years ago, LifeWay Research embarked on a comprehensive study of spiritual growth among churchgoers and the degree to which churches actually were producing biblical disciples and not merely churchgoers. That study identified eight common attributes of the Christian life that lead to spiritual health in a believer.
The eight signposts include Bible engagement, obeying God and denying self, serving God and others, sharing Christ, exercising faith, seeking God, building relationships and living a life unashamed of Jesus Christ.
Researchers conducted the phone survey of 1,000 Protestant pastors Aug. 29 to Sept. 11, 2018. The calling list was a stratified random sample, drawn from a list of all Protestant churches and using quotas for church size. Each interview was conducted with the senior pastor, minister or priest of the church called. Analysts weighted responses by region to reflect the population more accurately. The completed sample is 1,000 surveys, providing 95 percent confidence that the sampling error does not exceed plus or minus 3.2 percent. Margins of error are higher in sub-groups.