Most evangelicals choose Trump but clear divide exists

  |  Source: LifeWay Research

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

NASHVILLE, Tenn.—Nine in 10 evangelicals are registered to vote, and few are undecided about their presidential choice.

A new LifeWay Research survey conducted Sept. 9-23 finds President Donald Trump with a sizable lead over Democratic nominee Joe Biden among likely voters with evangelical beliefs. Deep divides, however, persist among evangelicals across ethnic lines.

Overall, 61 percent of evangelicals by belief plan to vote for Trump and 29 percent for Biden. Other candidates garner around 2 percent combined. Fewer than 1 in 10 (8 percent) are undecided.



Evangelicals by belief are also twice as likely to identify as a Republican (51 percent) than a Democrat (23 percent). One in 5 (20 percent) say they are independent.

“Voting for or against an incumbent president is a more certain situation for voters,” said Scott McConnell, executive director of LifeWay Research. “Fewer Americans, including those with evangelical beliefs, are on the fence than at this same point in 2016.”

Voting plans for Americans without evangelical beliefs are almost the mirror opposite of their evangelical counterparts, with Biden holding a commanding 56 percent to 33 percent lead over Trump.



Major differences in Black and white evangelicals

Trump’s advantage among evangelicals, however, comes primarily from white evangelicals, among whom he leads Biden 73 percent to 18 percent.

African Americans with evangelical beliefs overwhelmingly plan to vote for Biden (69 percent to 19 percent). Among American evangelicals of other ethnicities, Trump has a 58 percent to 32 percent lead.

Compared to a previous LifeWay Research survey conducted in the months leading up to the 2016 election, more white evangelicals say they plan to vote for Trump this time (73 percent to 65 percent). However, more also say they plan to vote for Biden than said they planned to vote for Hillary Clinton, the Democratic nominee four years ago, (18 percent to 10 percent).


Sign up for our weekly email newsletter.


While almost a quarter of white evangelicals were undecided or supporters of a third party in 2016, few say the same in 2020. Only 2 percent back a third-party candidate this year, compared to 8 percent four years ago. And while 16 percent were undecided in 2016, that number fell to 7 percent this year.

Individuals with evangelical beliefs who identify with the two largest political parties plan to be loyal to their party’s candidate. Among Republicans with evangelical beliefs, 91 percent say they are voting for Trump. Eight in 10 Democrats with evangelical beliefs (81 percent) support Biden.

“Different ethnic groups are more attuned to specific failures of our country and of specific candidates,” McConnell said. “One’s ethnicity and political party are more powerful in predicting the vote of someone with evangelical beliefs than their shared religious convictions alone.”



Among likely voters who identify as Christian and attend church at least once a month, support for Trump and Biden is evenly split (46 percent to 45 percent). As with evangelicals, ethnic divides are also present among churchgoers.

White churchgoers back Trump 59 percent to 30 percent, while African American churchgoers are solidly behind Biden (86 percent to 9 percent). The former vice president also has a sizeable—though smaller—lead among Hispanic churchgoers (58 percent to 36 percent) and churchgoers of other ethnicities (49 percent to 36 percent).

What really matters to voters

Improving the economy and fighting the pandemic are the top characteristics registered voters say they are looking for in a presidential candidate. Evangelicals agree but are much more likely also to point to abortion and religious liberty as factors.



A majority of registered voters say an ability to improve the economy (72 percent), slowing the spread of COVID-19 (58 percent) and maintaining national security (55 percent) are important factors in deciding their vote.

Close to half say the same about addressing racial injustice (49 percent), personal character (48 percent) and the candidate’s position on immigration (48 percent).

In the survey, which began prior to Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death, a third (33 percent) say likely Supreme Court nominees are an important factor. Similar numbers point to the candidate’s ability to protect religious freedom (32 percent), their position on abortion (31 percent) and their position on the size and role of government (30 percent).

Trump voters are more likely than Biden voters to say the economy (82 percent), national security (67 percent), immigration (62 percent), religious freedom (49 percent), abortion (44 percent), Supreme Court nominees (42 percent), and the size and role of government (40 percent) are important issues in determining their vote.

Biden voters are more likely than Trump voters to point to COVID-19 (75 percent), racial injustice (68 percent) and personal character (66 percent).

When asked the single most important issue in determining their vote, 26 percent of registered voters point to the economy, 22 percent say slowing the spread of COVID-19 and 15 percent say personal character. No other issue garners more than 8 percent.

Among evangelicals by belief registered to vote, improving the economy (22 percent) and slowing COVID-19 (16 percent) remain the top issues, but the candidates’ position on abortion (11 percent), and ability to protect religious freedom (11 percent) are more likely to be the top priority compared to those without evangelical beliefs.

Character counts?  Not so much

Fewer evangelicals (8 percent) than other Americans (16 percent) say the personal character of the presidential candidate is the most important issue in deciding their vote.

“Most evangelicals are not single-issue voters,” McConnell said. “Eighty-nine percent of those with evangelical beliefs selected more than one important issue that is influencing their vote. Like other Americans, their top concerns reflect the current recession and pandemic, but more than 1 in 10 with evangelical beliefs will vote for the candidate they think will protect religious freedom.”

LifeWay Research also asked registered voters, “Who do you hope your presidential vote benefits the most?” More than a third (35 percent) say people nationwide who are like them, and 22 percent say people who our country has failed.

Fewer say they hope the ones who benefit the most from their vote are themselves and their family (17 percent), people nationwide who are different from them (10 percent) or people in their community or region (7 percent).

Evangelical voters are more likely than other registered voters to say they hope their vote most benefits people nationwide who are like them (41 percent to 34 percent).

Registered voters with evangelical beliefs are also less likely to say they hope their vote most benefits people our country has failed (15 percent to 24 percent).

“Few Americans with evangelical beliefs will be casting a ‘Good Samaritan’ vote on election day,” McConnell said. “Instead, most will vote to benefit those like them or their own family.”

Those voting for Trump are more likely to say they hope their vote most benefits themselves and their family (21 percent to 14 percent of Biden voters) and people nationwide who are like them (43 percent to 31 percent).

Biden voters are more likely to say they are casting their vote in hopes that it most benefits people who our country has failed (32 percent to 10 percent of Trump voters).

The online survey of 1,200 Americans was conducted Sept. 9-23, 2020 using a national pre-recruited panel. Analysts used quotas and slight weights to balance gender, age, region, ethnicity, education and religion to reflect the population more accurately. The completed sample is 1,200 surveys, providing 95 percent confidence the sampling error from the panel does not exceed plus or minus 3.2 percent. Margins of error are higher in sub-groups.


We seek to inform, inspire and challenge you to live like Jesus. Click to learn more about Following Jesus.

If we achieved our goal—or didn’t—we’d love to hear from you. Send an email to Eric Black, our editor. Maximum length for publication is 250 words.

More from Baptist Standard


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email