WACO—Married women who live in communities where a higher proportion of the population belongs to conservative religious traditions—such as evangelical or Mormon—are more likely to choose not to work outside the home, even if the women are not members of those faith groups, according to a Baylor University study.
The study—“Work-Family Conflict: The Effects of Religious Context on Married Women’s Participation in the Labor Force”—appears in the journal Religions in a special issue, “Religion, Spirituality and Family Life.”
While previous research has shown individual women’s religious beliefs affect career decisions, this study argues the religious context of a geographic area also influences women’s solutions to work-family conflict.
Women today are faced with increasing demands from family and work, leading to more work-family conflict, researchers concluded. Combined with communal family expectations, this can cause many women to decrease the amount they work or exit the labor force altogether. Views of the “ideal family” in terms of family roles and responsibilities are influenced by community norms—including religion, wrote researcher Jenna Griebel Rogers, a doctoral candidate in the department of sociology at Baylor.
Communities have ‘a feeling all their own’
“Communities come to have a feeling all their own, and that sense of what makes one community different than another comes from the collective beliefs, values and expectations of all members of that community,” said co-researcher Aaron B. Franzen, a former Baylor sociology researcher and assistant professor of sociology at Hope College.
“On some level, this will influence people within the community, even if they have not personally ‘bought into’ a belief,” he said. “Since religious beliefs often have something to say about family life, we wanted to see if this had a communal effect. As some religious traditions, such as evangelicals and Mormons, have more traditional views of the mother’s role, we thought communities with a greater concentration of those beliefs would be tied to whether women worked outside the home.”
For their analysis, researchers used data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey for the years 2006-2010. The annual survey compiles statistics about the country’s social, economic and housing characteristics. Researchers also used data from InfoGroup’s 2009 Religion Reports, available through the Association of Religion Data Archives, limiting their study to married women ages 18 to 65 and identifying women who were working, temporarily laid off and actively looking for work.
Researchers’ analysis showed:
• Communities with a larger proportion of mainline Protestants had a greater number of married women in the workforce.
• Communities with larger proportions of evangelical, Mormon or Jewish individuals had fewer women in the labor force.
• There was no significant relationship between the Catholic proportion of a community and the proportion of working women.