Former Baylor law prof: Jesus’ death convicts capital punishment

Baptists and other Christians opposed to the death penalty say death chambers like this one violate the spirit of Christ’s own unjust death. (Creative Commons photo by Tommy Woodard)

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

MINNEAPOLIS, Minn. (BNG)—On Good Friday, Christians around the world remember the day a government punished a convicted criminal with the death penalty. For many Christians—including some Baptists—Jesus’ death inspires them to oppose the death penalty for others.

mark osler425Former Baylor law professor and prosecutor Mark Osler tries to convince congregations to sentence Jesus to death (Thomas Whisenand/University of St. Thomas)Count among them Mark Osler, who as a law professor at Baylor University wrote Jesus on Death Row: The Trial of Jesus and American Capital Punishment.

A former federal prosecutor who won a case in the U.S. Supreme Court, he used his book to draw parallels between Jesus’ conviction and the U.S. justice system. Osler played the prosecutor in a theatrical version of the book performed in 11 states.

Osler, who now teaches at the University of St. Thomas School of Law, describes in his forthcoming book, Memoirs of Christ’s Prosecutor, how he connected opposition to the death penalty to his faith while taking communion at Seventh and James Baptist Church in Waco. Earlier, he had read a newspaper account of an execution.

book osler160The bread “in my hand represented the last meal of a man who knew he was about to be executed,” he explains in the book’s introduction.

“There is something deeply ironic about the enthusiasm many Christians have for the death penalty,” he writes. “The central narrative of Christianity, after all, is about an unjust execution, and Christians proudly wear the execution device as a symbol of their faith.”

Osler grounded his opposition to the death penalty in biblical narratives—for instance, in John 8, “where Jesus stops a legal execution not by questioning the charge or the punishment, but the moral authority of the executioners,” he noted.

He also pointed to biblical narratives in the Sermon on Mount in which Jesus gave “a direct rejection of the ‘eye-for-an-eye’ argument.”

“Finally, when Jesus teaches that if we visit those in prison, we visit him, he is expressly equating himself to those we wish to execute,” Osler added. “Doesn’t that mitigate against killing?”

A call for the end of the death penalty

On the Tuesday before Easter this year, nearly 400 Christian leaders, theologians and pastors issued a public statement calling for the abolition of capital punishment in the United States.

“Torture and execution is always a profound evil, made even more abhorrent when sanctioned by the government in the name of justice when other means of protecting society are available,” the authors wrote.

“All who reverence the sanctity of human life, created in the image of God, must never remain silent when firing squads, lethal injections, electric chairs and other instruments of death are viewed as morally acceptable.”

death penalty protest425A 2010 protest in Geneva. (Creative Commons photo by the World Coalition Against the Death Penalty)Nearly two dozen Baptists signed the Holy Week statement, including author Tony Campolo; Jonathan Davis at Urbanna Baptist Church in Urbanna, Va.; David Gushee at Mercer University; James Lamkin at Northside Drive Baptist Church in Atlanta, Ga.; Suzii Paynter, executive coordinator of the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship; Julie Pennington-Russell at First Baptist Church of Decatur, Ga.; Stephen Stacks at Greenwood Forest Baptist Church in Cary, N.C.; Raphael Warnock at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, Ga.; and author Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove at St. Johns Baptist Church in Durham, N.C.

The pastor of the church Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal attends, William Coates at First Baptist Church of Gainesville, added his name to the statement. Coates and other Baptists earlier this year urged Deal to stay the execution of Kelly Gissendaner, who completed a prison-based seminary program created by the McAfee School of Theology at Mercer University and other seminaries.

Winter weather prevented Gissendaner’s February execution, and concerns about lethal injection drugs stopped her rescheduled March execution. A new date has not yet been set.

Justin Thornburgh, pastor of Emerson Avenue Baptist Church in Indianapolis, also signed the Holy Week statement. Thornburgh said he focuses his comments on Jesus when talking with Christians who believe the Bible authorizes the death penalty.

‘What is the essence of the gospel?’

“What did Jesus preach? What is the essence of the gospel?” he asked. “My reading of it is that the essence of the gospel is redemption. Christ was killed by capital punishment, and what we have is that God triumphed over that with the resurrection.

“I believe the message of Christ is a message of redemption and reconciliation as opposed to revenge. The ethos of Christ is love, and Christ saw everyone as worthy of redemption.”

American Baptist Churches USA officially condemned capital punishment on several occasions, passing resolutions calling for the abolition of the death penalty in 1958, 1966, 1980, 1982, 1992 and 2000.

The resolutions highlight “the sacredness of life,” “the fallibility of human agencies and legal justice,” financial and racial inequality, and “the hope and possibility of all to come under the redeeming and transforming action of God.”

The resolutions also urge American Baptists to advocate for legal changes and to work to stop executions.

Polling by the Public Religion Research Institute in September 2014 found white evangelical Protestants remain the most likely religious demographic to support the death penalty over life in prison for murderers. Favoring the death penalty by a 59 percent to 34 percent margin, they outpace overall American opinion that supports life in prison by a 48 percent to 44 percent margin.

White Catholics favor life in prison by a 50 percent to 45 percent margin, while Black Protestants favor life in prison by a 68 percent to 25 percent margin.

Southern Baptist resolution supporting capital punishment

A 2000 resolution passed by the Southern Baptist Convention supported capital punishment, and top Southern Baptist leaders have reiterated that position.

Last year, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary President Al Mohler wrote a CNN.com piece supporting capital punishment. He attacked the “moral insanity” of death penalty critics who “have successfully diverted attention from a murderer’s heinous crimes and instead put the death penalty on trial.”

“I believe that Christians should hope, pray and strive for a society in which the death penalty, rightly and rarely applied, would make moral sense,” he added.

Although Mohler cited some Scripture in his column, author and anti-death penalty activist Shane Claiborne noted in a blog post Mohler never mentioned Jesus.

“If it weren’t for Jesus, I might be pro-death too,” Claiborne wrote.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

Care to comment? Send an email to Eric Black, our editor. Maximum length for publication is 250 words.