Editorial: Churches are afraid, what to do
Lifeway Research released study results Aug. 8 that find growing fear among Protestant churches in the United States. How many churches are afraid, of what and why?
Numbers and whats are quantifiable and definable, making them easier to handle than whys. Numbers and whats feel safe, because we can handle them at arm’s length without feeling implicated. But whys? Whys can get personal.
Like the squirrel that scampers to the other side of the tree trunk from us—because an unseen threat doesn’t exist—we’ll put numbers and whats between us and the whys so we don’t have to acknowledge the latter.
Like Grover despairing over the monster at the end of the book—almost moving heaven and earth to keep the reader from turning one more page, narrowing the distance to the end—we’ll do anything to avoid the whys.
Spoiler alert: There is a monster at the end of the book, and that monster is us. Like Grover, we don’t know yet if that monster is friend or foe. Unlike Grover, we’re not in a silly story. The story we’re in has some really consequential numbers, whats and whys.
We need to get to the whys, but before we do, I’ll answer the numbers and whats questions from above.
Fear by the numbers
Lifeway Research reported almost 70 percent of Protestant pastors in the United States see their churches growing more fearful “about the future of the nation and world.” About 63 percent are more fearful specifically “about the future of Christianity” in the nation and world.
The most fearful group in the survey were white respondents, at 71 percent. About 72 percent of Baptist pastors see this fear for the future in their churches. Churches with less than 50 in attendance were reported as the most likely to have “a growing fear about the future.”
Percentages are somewhat lower than they were in 2014 and 2010—even with the intervening pandemic years—but they’re still high enough to pass a motion requiring a two-thirds vote.
Furthermore, Scott McConnell—executive director of Lifeway Research—expressed what I take to be concern that even though percentages have decreased, “a large majority of pastors see their congregations moving toward fear rather than away from it” (emphasis added).
According to the numbers, there is a lot of concern in our churches. That concern is about the future. But “concern” isn’t the word used in the study. The word used is “fear.” And it’s growing—according to the research.
What’s so scary?
As already stated, churches are growing in fear about the future, but left unstated is what about the future is causing so much fear. The survey names the future of the nation, the world and Christianity, but it does not specify what about the future of those three is generating fear.
Could it be: (A) lower standard of living, (B) financial insecurity, (C) poor health, (D) political instability, (E) decreased safety, (F) church closure, (G) religious persecution, (H) all the above, (I) other: please specify?
I was a pastor of a small Baptist church in a rural, low-income and predominantly white community. People in my church and community were concerned—and plenty were fearful—about several of the options listed above. In the five years since, I doubt their concerns have subsided.
During the last five years, as I’ve been in regular contact with pastors, ministry leaders and churches all over Texas and beyond, I know many share the same concerns—especially during and after 2020 and 2021.
Many of us have enjoyed decades—generations, even—of prosperity, and we don’t want to experience life without it. Life without safety, security, stability, good health and an overall high standard of living entails some degree of suffering. No, we certainly don’t want that.
And now we’re to an important why—a reason so many churches are afraid.
Why churches are afraid
Many churches are afraid the future is going to be worse than the present, which many of them consider to be worse than the past. But here again, I’m at arm’s length with the phrase “churches are afraid.”
To be more precise: Many of us—you and I—are afraid the future is going to be worse than the present, and many of us consider the present to be worse than the past.
We know intuitively that safety, security, stability, good health and an overall high standard of living are not givens. None of them are guaranteed, and none of them are the natural state of things. Each requires commitment, hard work, cooperation and God’s grace.
Even with all of that, we also know intuitively whatever measure we have of any of these things isn’t going to and doesn’t last forever. We fear their loss.
Our fear drives us to all kinds of unproductive things—paralysis, fighting, obsession, to name a few. There is a better way.
Prepare for the future
We would do better to agree with our intuition, to celebrate what good we enjoy and to prepare ourselves for life without it.
Instead of the typical ways we respond to loss and the threat of loss, we would do better to train ourselves to respond with Christlikeness to our inevitable losses.
For example, while advocating for religious liberty, we should give equal time to practicing how we will respond to persecution in Christlikeness when persecution comes. While maintaining fiscal responsibility, we should imagine how we will “do church” to God’s glory if one day we no longer can afford a building.
Our preparation for our future should be greater than our fear of it.
Let us not be characterized by our fear about the future, which ultimately includes God’s complete restoration of all things, including us. Let us instead be known by our trust in Christ whose lived example can prepare us for the rough times before our restoration.
Eric Black is the executive director, publisher and editor of the Baptist Standard. He can be reached at [email protected]. The views expressed are those of the author.